Classic French technique meets a kosher-friendly Thanksgiving upgrade! Before I kept kosher, I learned to rub butter under and over the turkey skin to keep it crispy. Now I keep kosher, so I use plant-based parve butter (neither meat nor dairy) infused with herbs and garlic. And honestly? It turned out even better: crispier and creamier than traditional butter.

What wine goes with herb-butter turkey breast?

A slightly oaked Chardonnay. I pour La Fenêtre Chardonnay from California's Santa Maria Valley (not mevushal, kosher for Passover). Its creamy texture mirrors the herb butter, and its bright acidity cuts through the garlic and fresh dill.

I served it with Russian-style boiled potatoes. Right after draining, I tossed them in that exact same herb-and-garlic butter with plenty of fresh dill. Simple, comforting, and so good!

What wine goes with herb-butter turkey breast?

The wrong wine can ruin even the best meal. That's why a sommelier is basically a flavor matchmaker, making sure your glass brings out the best on your plate instead of fighting it.

A slightly oaked Chardonnay (just a light touch of oak barrel) is the sweet spot here. Its creamy texture mirrors the velvety richness of the herb butter. Its bright acidity (that mouth-watering freshness) cuts through the garlic and fresh dill. My pick is La Fenêtre Chardonnay from California's Santa Maria Valley. That's the beauty of a good wine pairing!

The pairing

Herb-butter turkey breast with dill potatoes&La Fenêtre Chardonnay

Its creamy texture mirrors the herb butter, and its bright acidity cuts through the garlic and fresh dill.

Bottle of La Fenêtre 2015 Chardonnay, Santa Maria Valley, front label, with a poured glass behind it

Tasting notes

2015 · Santa Maria Valley, California · 12% alcohol

  • Mevushal No
  • Passover Kosher for Passover
Taste
Slightly oaked and creamy, rich enough for the herb butter, with bright, crisp acidity
  • Aciditymouth-watering freshnessFresh

Watch the video

Reel cover: Anne raising a glass of Chardonnay over sliced herb-butter turkey breast, a bowl of dill potatoes and a bottle of La Fenêtre Chardonnay. Press play to watch the video.

Watch on YouTube, and subscribe for new pairings.

In the kitchen

Sliced herb-butter turkey breast with crisp, peppery skin on a white plate, next to a bowl of boiled potatoes with dill

How to Make Herb-Butter Turkey Breast with Russian Dill Potatoes

  • Cook about 40 min
  • Meat

Ingredients

For the herb-garlic butter

  • Plant-based parve butter, softened
  • Fresh herbs, chopped
  • Garlic, chopped

For the turkey

  • Turkey breast, skin on
  • Salt
  • Pepper

For the potatoes

  • Potatoes
  • Plenty of fresh dill, chopped

Method

  1. Mix the softened parve butter with the herbs and garlic.
  2. Heat the oven to 450°F.
  3. Gently lift the turkey skin and rub herb butter, salt and pepper underneath it.
  4. Rub more herb butter, salt and pepper over the skin. Save the leftover butter for the potatoes.
  5. Roast at 450°F for 20 minutes.
  6. Lower the oven to 375°F and roast for about 20 minutes more, until a thermometer in the thickest part reads 160°F.
  7. Tent loosely with foil and rest for 20 minutes. The turkey keeps cooking as it rests, so check that the thickest part reaches 165°F, the USDA safe minimum for poultry, before slicing.
  8. Boil the potatoes until tender, then drain.
  9. Immediately toss the hot potatoes with the leftover herb-garlic butter and plenty of fresh dill.
  10. Slice the turkey and serve it with the potatoes.

More for your Thanksgiving table: my babushka's Cranberry Bliss Cake and, for more parve garlic butter with a Chardonnay, my kosher chicken Kyiv.

Save this one for Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving, and L'Chaim!